Friday 5 May 2017

Is the Government a beneficiary of Samuel Abisai's 221 million?

A number of friends have asked me how betting is currently being taxed in Kenya.  I have seen a number of discussions on both print and social media  on this subject and there seems to be a little confusion on how it’s being done. From whom should the tax be chargeable? What is the correct rate of tax? is there withholding Tax on winnings? 

First, taxation on winnings has evolved in the last decade. The Government has struggled to arrive at the best approach for taxing this sector which is a multi billion-shilling industry. Its main agenda is to raise revenue as well as discourage betting obviously because of the well known negative effects.  Different jurisdictions have adopted different styles.

For simplicity I will divide it into two parts:
1    1. Taxes on Bookmakers (companies)

There are four categories provided for under the Betting, Lotteries and Gaming Act.
    v  Betting tax – payable by the betting company at the rate of 7.5% (sec 29A) of the gross turnover less the amount paid to customers as winnings.
    v  Lottery tax – payable by the lottery company at the rate of 5%( Sec 44A)  of the lottery turnover.
    v  Gaming tax- payable by the gaming company at the rate of  12% (sect 55A )of the gross turnover less the amount paid to customers as winnings.
    v  Prize Competition Tax – chargeable on  the  cost  of  entry  to  a  competition  which  is  premium rated  at  the  rate  of  15% (Sec 59B ) of  the  total  gross turnover.  

Note all the three taxes have been standardized to a rate of 50 % w.e.f 1st Jan, 2018 (Refer to section 26-29 of the Finance Bill 2017). All these are paid by the bookmaker to the Collector (KRA) by the 20th of the  month following the month of collection( just like VAT). 

2        2. Taxes on punters (winners)

Previously withholding tax at the rate of 20% gross winnings was chargeable. Through the finance Act 2015 the rate was reduced to 7.5% w.e.f 1st Jan 2016. Later, through   the Finance Act 2016, this was removed from the Income Tax Act and the model of taxing bookmakers and not punters was adopted. The rates are as explained above. 

The Big Question,
Can then Samuel declare the winnings in his income tax return and pay tax at the graduated individual scale?  Please note that individuals don't pay taxes at the rate of 30%- that’s discussion for another day.

The simple answer is, although in my opinion it would be necessary to declare the winnings in the return, the money may not be taxed. Whether winnings are treated as taxable income is an issue that has been contested a lot. There have been a number of case laws on this subject. The fundamental question is whether winnings should be treated as taxable income. This would also mean that the punter (winner) be allowed to offset his losses against that particular income which is the case in some jurisdictions. Some have argued that betting is more of a hobby than a business. Post 2017,  Income Tax Act does not treat winnings as taxable income. Betting, gaming and lottery services are also exempted from VAT (refer to the first schedule).  

Conclusion. Samuel may just  end up keeping all his money. What? I know, and that also explains why when you “sportpesa” and win that 3k, no taxes are withheld.





Disclaimer:
The views expressed in this article are my own and do not reflect the position taken by  Kenya Revenue Authority on this matter.